A Threat Assessment Framework for Screening the Integrity of University Assessments in the Era of Large Language Models

Creator(s)

Alan Hickey, Cathal Ó Faoláin, Emer Doheny, John Healy, Kevin Nolan, Paul Cuffe

Organisation(s)

University College Dublin

Discipline(s)

Education, Engineering, Generic programmes and qualifications, Manufacturing and Construction, Teaching & Learning

Topic(s)

Assessment & Feedback, Curriculum Design, Learning Analytics, Open Education

License

CC BY-SA

Media Format

PDF, PDF document

Date Submitted

Submitted by

Export Resource Data

Description

A. Hickey, C. O’Faolain, J. Healy, K. Nolan, E. Doheny and P. Cuffe, “A Threat Assessment Framework for Screening the Integrity of University Assessments in the Era of Large Language Models”, presented at 8th IEEE International Forum on Research and Technologies for Society and Industry Innovation, Lecco, Italy, September 2024

Benefit of this resource and how to make the best use of it

Since late 2022, the sudden growth in the availability and capabilities of generative artificial intelligence tools, such as Large Language Models, has raised concerns about the threat they pose to the integrity of assessment in educational institutions. Such models are constantly evolving and improving, making the task of understanding exactly what they can do more difficult. Recognising this challenge, this paper establishes a Large Language Model exposure framework to qualitatively and quantitatively examine the assessment strategies of university modules to provide a high-level estimated indication of the exposure of these modules to potential dishonest use of such models in the completion of their assessments and coursework. This framework may be used and adapted when planning and reviewing teaching and learning practices and policies.

Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA)

This work is licensed under a CC BY-SA license, allowing adaptation and sharing with proper attribution, provided derivative works use the same license.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
? This citation is automatically generated and may not be perfectly formatted. Always check and adjust it according to your required citation style.
Hickey, A., Faoláin, C. Ó., Doheny, E., Healy, J., Nolan, K., & Cuffe, P. (2025). A threat assessment framework for screening the integrity of university assessments in the era of large language models. National Resource Hub (Ireland). Retrieved from: https://hub.teachingandlearning.ie/resource/a-threat-assessment-framework-for-screening-the-integrity-of-university-assessments-in-the-era-of-large-language-models/

Adapted this resource? Share your version!

If you have modified or adopted this resource, share your version here. Tracking adaptations helps us measure impact and connects others with useful updates.

Related OER

This open course is designed to facilitate the development of your Artificial Intelligence (AI) literacy so that you can explore and innovate using Generative AI (GenAI) within your teaching, learning, and assessment practices.

In light of the potential opportunities and challenges of these technologies, this course will facilitate you in exploring the fundamentals of GenAI and AI Literacy, whilst focusing on an ethical practice. You will consider innovative ways in which you can respond to the challenges arising from the impact of these technologies in Higher Education.

Completion of this course will support you in developing a GenAI teaching strategy to apply to your own practice.

This short guide provides an overview of GenAI and a longer discussion of how assessments can be (re)designed to integrate or limit the use of GenAI by students. It includes examples from teaching practice at University College Cork.

We were both impressed and worried to witness the rapid escalation in the ability of tools like ChatGPT to conjure credible-seeming scholarly prose ex-nihilo. Rather than leaving the assessment strategy in MEEN3010 exposed to AI plagiarism, we decided to shift the focus towards a more authentic and interactive learning activity; a poster session.

Report an Issue

Name