Resource

Assessing work-integrated learning: developing solutions to the challenges of authenticity and consistency

Assessment and FeedbackNational Forum Insights

Description

Preliminary fellowship findings on balancing authenticity and consistency in work-integrated learning assessment, with recommendations on stakeholder dialogue, student empowerment, competencies and support for assessors.

Benefit of this resource and how to make the best use of it

This April 2022 National Forum Insight summarises the background and preliminary findings of Geraldine O’Neill’s Teaching and Learning Research Fellowship at University College Dublin, which concluded in December 2021. The research explores how assessment and feedback in work-integrated learning can be both authentic—meaningful and connected to real work—and consistent across different settings and assessors.

The study combines analysis of 93,733 open-ended StudentSurvey.ie responses from 2016–20, interviews with seven researchers, and nine participatory workshops involving 120 students, educators and workplace practitioners. It considers work-integrated learning both on campus and on placement, examining challenges and potential solutions across disciplines and assessment arrangements.

Emerging recommendations address clearer expectations and dialogue among stakeholders, student empowerment and assessment literacy, manageable competencies, grading approaches, and support and recognition for workplace assessors. The Insight also highlights the importance students place on practical learning and employability. It presents initial findings and proposed directions for policy and practice, rather than the completed analysis of the fellowship research.

How it can be used

  • Prompt programme-team discussion about balancing authentic learning experiences with fair and consistent assessment.
  • Review the clarity of assessment expectations and the roles of students, educators and workplace practitioners.
  • Inform conversations about competencies, feedback, student self-evaluation and grading in work-integrated learning.
  • Explore participatory workshops as a way to identify assessment challenges and develop shared actions with stakeholders.

People, communities and initiatives

Contributors

Geraldine O’Neill

Communities

Initiatives

Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY)

This work is licensed under a CC BY license, allowing sharing and adaptation with proper attribution.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Access this resource

Links open in a new tab.

Additional files

Ancillary, supplementary or associated files…

Additional resource information

Resource details

Media format

Licence

Resource created

File attachments

Share this resource

Report an issue

Adapting this resource? Share your version!

If you have modified or adopted this resource, share your version here. Tracking adaptations helps us measure impact and connects others with useful updates.