Initiative

Rethinking the Crit

Teaching and Learning Enhancement Fund 2014-18
Digital Learning, Professional Development, Student Success

About this initiative

Assessment in architecture and creative arts schools has traditionally adopted a ‘one size fits all’ approach by using the ‘crit’, where students pin up their work, make a presentation and receive verbal feedback in front of peers and academic staff. In addition to increasing stress and inhibiting learning, which may have a greater or lesser impact depending on gender and ethnicity, the adversarial structure of the ‘crit’ reinforces power imbalances and thereby ultimately contributes to the reproduction of dominant cultural paradigms. Our proposal brings customised feedback methods and blended learning to new assessment methods in a radical approach challenging the dominant pedagogical theory and practice in architecture internationally. The feedback on the pilot from students, academic staff, external examiners and members of the professional body has been extremely positive. With the funding, we are now in the process of reviewing emergent best practice abroad and have brought in international experts to evaluate and develop our approach. While our focus will be on architecture, it will be relevant to other disciplines which use the ‘crit’ method, in particular creative arts disciplines. This new approach has the potential to give students greater agency, enhanced critical faculties, professional skills and resilience, with the student becoming central to the learning process.

Lead organisations

Technological University Dublin

Affiliated organisations

Munster Technological University

University College Dublin

University of Limerick

Linked open educational resources

Initiative details

Funding programmes Teaching and Learning Enhancement Fund 2014-18
Themes Digital LearningProfessional DevelopmentStudent Success
Status
Completed
Award year
2018
End year
2019

Project lead

Orna Hanly

Contributors

Patrick Flynn
Mark Price
Maureen O’Connor
Miriam Dunn